I hadn’t had one of these rolls in years (probably since I was an undergrad and my friend Danny and I tried to visit every all-you-can-eat buffet in Charlottesville—we failed). However, Jon recently mentioned these buttery delights and I began a long quest to try to recreate this flavor memory from childhood.
After many pitiful, failed attempts, I think I finally nailed it. The trick to perfecting this dough is time and patience—neither of which I’m particularly known for possessing. I unveiled my version of the “steakhouse roll” at Friend Thanksgiving last weekend. As you can imagine, I love Thanksgiving more than most every other holiday and enjoy sharing the occasion with both family and friends. My pal Robin hosted a fantastic vegetarian feast for a number of our friends and it was certainly something to give thanks for.

If you decide to try these rolls for your Thanksgiving this year, allow yourself plenty of time to fool with them. There is a lot of idle time while the dough is rising so you can accomplish other tasks, but it is very important that you not rush the process. With a little patience and a lot of butter, you can wow your guests with a showstopper.

4 tablespoons and 3 tablespoons butter, separated
1/3 cup vegetable shortening
¾ cup and 1 tablespoon granulated sugar
3 extra large eggs
4 1/4 ounce packages active dry yeast
1 teaspoon honey
½ cup lukewarm water
7 ½ cups all-purpose flour
1 tablespoon kosher salt
1 ¼ cups milk
1 teaspoon olive oil
Using an electric mixer, cream butter and shortening with sugar until light and fluffy. Add eggs slowly, one at a time, and blend to create a homogenous mixture.
Warm ½ cup of water to about 110 degrees F. Warm water from the faucet will often suffice, but make sure that the water is not too hot. Dissolve the yeast in the water and add the honey to the mixture.
Sift flour and salt. Add half of the flour and half of the milk to the shortening-butter mixture and mix until just combined. Add the dissolved yeast and mix until incorporated. Finally, add the remaining milk and flour and mix to form a soft dough. Cover the dough with plastic wrap and allow it to rest for about 10 minutes.
Lightly flour your working surface and turn dough out. Knead the dough for 8 to 10 minutes or until elastic and smooth.
Grease a large bowl with olive oil and place the dough inside, turning once to evenly coat the outer surface of the dough. Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and set aside in a warm place (about 90 degrees F) until the dough has doubled in size (this generally takes about 2 hours).
Turn dough onto working surface and knead lightly. Return the dough to the bowl and allow it to rise again until doubled in size (about 1 additional hour). Preheat oven to 350 degrees F and line a baking sheet with parchment paper. When the dough has risen again, turn it onto the working surface and shape pieces into rounds a bit smaller than a tennis ball. Place the rounds about an inch apart on the baking sheet. Brush the tops of each roll with melted butter and set aside in a warm area and allow to rise for about 30 minutes.
Then, bake the rolls at 350 degrees F for 10 to 12 minutes, until the tops are gold brown and slightly crisp. Remove the rolls from the oven and immediately brush tops with butter again and serve warm.
(Yields: 24 rolls; Ready In: 4 hours)
